Preventive Law for Employers
NJ Employment Law

Good News for Employers! Disloyal Employee Forced to Repay Salary

The “faithless servant doctrine” may sound old-fashioned, but it can be a powerful tool for employers that are the victims of disloyal employees. This 19th century remedy allows companies to get back the salary and other compensation paid to the bad apple. Why? The courts have reasoned that the wrongdoer didn’t really “earn” that compensation..

Unanimously, the  New Jersey Supreme Court recently ruled that an employer can recover the salary of an employee who breaches his duty of loyalty to the employer. Here’s what happened.

Alan Rosefielde was hired to act as Chief Operating Officer for three related companies that sold and managed timeshares at vacation spots on the Jersey Shore, at the hefty salary of $500,000. Over the next two years, Rosefielde committed serious misconduct by, among other things: giving himself a 10% interest in one of the three companies, when it should have gone to another employee; hoodwinking the companies’ principal by telling him that the signature page he was executing was for a trust for the owner’s son, instead of an agreement giving Rosefielde a 10% management fee on top of his salary; lying to an insurance company by telling it that independent sales reps were employees, so they could be put on the health insurance plan; billing his employer for trip to Las Vegas where he did no business, but rather stayed in a hotel suite with three women who were adult film stars; forging signatures on quitclaim deeds from timeshare owners who had defaulted on payments; and, making sexual advances to two female subordinates. When Rosefielde’s misconduct was discovered, he was fired.

The employer then sued Rosefielde, alleging claims for breach of the duty of loyalty and seeking to recover the salary it had paid Rosefielde, also referred to as the remedy of equitable disgorgement. In a unanimous opinion, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled in favor of the employer, explaining that when an employee abuses his position, he fails to meet the employer’s legitimate expectation of loyalty in the performance of the job duties for which he is paid. The justices also noted that disgorgement has the valuable deterrent effect of telling employees that there can be severe consequences for breaching of their duty of loyalty, and clarified that disgorgement of a disloyal employee’s salary should be limited to the period during which the employee breached the duty of loyalty. Kaye v. Rosefielde, ____ N.J. ____ (Sep. 22, 2015)

What this case means to you:

In appropriate situations, disgorgement can be a powerful remedy for a deceived employer. Disloyal employees are now on notice that forfeiture of their prior compensation is fair game for their employers.


Comments are closed.

Who is Ann Kiernan?

Ann Kiernan is an employment lawyer who has been practicing law in New Jersey for more than 30 years. She represents only employers and management and regularly provides management training companies big and small. Employment law is constantly changing, and Ann is familiar how these changes affect employers. To keep up-to-date and learn what issues are currently affecting businesses and employers in New Jersey, read the blog.

Contacting Ann Kieran

The Law Office of Ann F. Kiernan is located at

210 New York Avenue
New Brunswick, NJ

Ann may be reached via telephone at 732-846-3201 and email.

Legal Disclaimer

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should not act or rely on any legal information on the World Wide Web without obtaining the advice of an attorney. The selection of an attorney is an important decision that should not be based solely on advertising. Before making your choice of attorney, you should give this matter careful thought. To learn more, click here.